十Christian Japan
Chapter IV · 1873 to 1945

The Church Rebuiltin a troubled time

After 1873 Japan's Catholics could worship in the open, and they built: brick cathedrals, stone churches on islands, schools and orphanages. But the freedom they were given came with conditions. What did it mean to be free under watch?

1,870 words28 sourcesTap any name, place or term to learn moreTimeline
Urakami Cathedral with its twin towers before 1945
Urakami Cathedral with its twin towers before 1945.Urakami Cathedral before the bombing. Unknown photographer, public domain (PD-Japan-oldphoto). Commons

The story

The chapter in eight steps. Each line is footnoted.

  1. 1873The notice boards come down; Christianity is tolerated by silence.
  2. 1874Dysentery and smallpox in Urakami; Father de Rotz and young women nurse the sick.
  3. 1880The Urakami Catholics buy the headman's house where they once trod on the fumi-e.
  4. 1889The Meiji Constitution grants freedom of belief, within limits.
  5. 1895 to 1925The returned exiles build Urakami Cathedral, coin by coin.
  6. 1927Hayasaka Kyūnosuke becomes the first Japanese bishop.
  7. 1932Two or three Sophia students do not salute at Yasukuni.
  8. 1939The Religious Organizations Law puts every religion under state control.

Every month, on set days, a French priest walked the lanes of Urakami with a satchel over his shoulder. Children ran ahead of him shouting that the priest was coming. Families came out with 5 or 10 sen, and he wrote each gift in a little book.

His name was Pierre-Théodore , of the Paris Foreign Missions Society, the son of a family of stonemasons and carpenters. He had arrived in Nagasaki in 1873, the year the exiles came home, and in 1888 he became their parish priest. He was collecting for a cathedral. When the bishop saw his plans and asked where the money would come from, Fraineau, by the parish's account, answered calmly: "It will come down from heaven." Tradition

It came down in copper coins from farmers who, fifteen years earlier, had come home from exile to find their houses gone.

1873 to 1889

Freedom within limits

On February 24, 1873, the government took down the notice boards that had banned Christianity since 1614. It did not proclaim religious freedom; it simply stopped saying the old ban out loud. In Nagasaki, Bishop Bernard Petitjean, the priest of the discovery, had spent the exile years writing to Rome. On May 29, 1873 Blessed Pius IX wrote to him in the brief Dum asperrimam to share his joy at the end of the persecution. "From this moment," the archive of the Paris Foreign Missions Society says, "the Japanese government showed itself disposed to tolerance," and Petitjean began to organize his vicariate. The returned exiles of Urakami came home to burned fields and empty house lots, and 736 had no house at all.

Missionaries counted about 15,000 Catholics attached to the restored Church in 1873, with thousands more still outside its organization.By the end of the year Japan had three churches, twenty-seven oratories and two seminaries with seventy pupils.The Nagasaki seminary opened in 1873, while twenty young men in Yokohama were taught lithography to print religious books.

Then disease came. In July 1874 dysentery broke out on Iōjima and spread to Urakami, followed by smallpox. Father Marc nursed the sick, helped by young returnees such as Iwanaga Maki; the community they formed raised orphans and became the Urakami .

In 1876 the government made Sunday an official day of rest, chiefly for administrative convenience rather than religious reasons.By March 1879 the Catholic mission counted 20,146 believers, church buildings in six cities and fifty-five chapels or oratories.Japan's Catholic population grew to 23,909 in 1880.

1880

The headman's house

The returnees wanted a church of their own. In 1880 the estate of the , the village headmen, came up for sale. It was the house where their families had been made to tread on the fumi-e every New Year, and where the exile had been announced. On June 4, 1880, the Urakami Catholics bought it for 1,600 yen and made it a temporary church. They held their first Mass there on August 15, the feast of the Assumption.

By the late 1880s more than 5,000 believers were spilling out of its doors at Sunday Mass.

Much of the Church's growth still depended on ordinary lay workers.Catechists, often married men who could move among their neighbors more freely than foreign priests, taught the faith, while communities of sisters trained women catechists.

1879 to 1919

Churches in the villages

The end of the ban changed the landscape of western Kyushu. The communities that rejoined the Church began building in the very hamlets where they had hidden, simple at first and then grander, as priest-builders such as de Rotz in Sotome and Urakami and Father Pelu in the Gotō Islands trained Japanese craftsmen. Ōura itself was rebuilt in brick in 1879 and blessed by Petitjean, by then a bishop, on May 22, 1879.

The Church also established a national hierarchy in 1891, with an archbishop in Tokyo and dioceses at Nagasaki, Osaka and Hakodate.By 1895 Japan had twenty Japanese priests alongside eighty-eight European missionaries and 169 churches and chapels.

Marc de Rotz, a member of the Paris Foreign Missions Society, landed in Nagasaki in 1868 and printed catechisms by lithograph at Ōura. From 1879 he was parish priest of Sotome, on the coast north of Nagasaki, among the descendants of the hidden Christians. He designed Shitsu Church himself and built it in 1882. In 1883 he added a workshop to help the village women support themselves, with a macaroni factory and a sardine-net works; he imported tools and taught people to use them with drawings. In 1893 he built a small chapel at Ōno for the 26 Christian households there, of local stone set in a mortar of red earth and lime, a technique now called the de Rotz wall. The villages of Shitsu and Ōno are now one of the twelve components of the UNESCO property "Hidden Christian Sites in the Nagasaki Region".

One of the craftsmen trained in this way was , a master carpenter from the upper Gotō Islands. He learned church building from Father de Rotz and Father Pelu, and was a Buddhist who came to understand the Christian spirit through his friendship with the priests. He went on to design and build more than thirty churches.

In 1908 he built the brick church of Nokubi on Nozaki Island, laid in English bond under a roof of Japanese tiles, with a ribbed vault inside. It is the work of Japanese carpenters, taught directly by European missionaries, joining Western and Japanese techniques.

At Ōso on Nakadōri Island, finished in 1916, he banded the brick walls with courses of dark over-fired brick and crowned the bell tower with an octagonal dome.

For the altar at Egami he drew ears of wheat and a fruiting vine, for the bread and the wine, with roses for Mary; the drawing, found in 2005, is dated June 21, 1917.

About thirty of his drawings survive. They were found when his old house at Maruo was demolished, conserved in 2016, and are now shown at the Geihinkan Museum in Arikawa.

The most remarkable of his churches stands on , a small island off the Gotō coast. Work began in 1910, and the families of a small hamlet put all their strength into it for ten years until it was finished in 1919. It is built of cut local sandstone, with an octagonal dome on its bell tower, and Nagasaki Prefecture calls it outstanding among the island churches. It was designated an Important Cultural Property on November 14, 2001.

Across the water the pattern repeated. Kuroshima, an island off Sasebo, had been settled in the 18th century partly by hidden Christians from Sotome. After 1873 the whole community rejoined the Church. In 1902 they finished one of the largest brick churches in Japan, designed by Father Joseph Marmand. On Fukue, in the Gotō Islands, Marmand had built a small wooden church at Dozaki in 1880. His successor, Father Pelu, planned a brick one, which the builder Nohara Yokichi completed in 1908.

The mission's work extended beyond church construction.By 1895 religious sisters operated ten orphanages caring for about 1,500 girls, and eight Japanese communities of women religious worked in education and charity in the south.Schools and lay catechists provided much of the Church's contact with communities far from its main churches.

The light inside those churches changed too. Stained glass made in Japan begins with Unosawa Tatsuo, who trained in Berlin and made his first Japanese work, for the Tokyo Prefectural Office, in 1894. At Egami on Naru Island, finished in 1918, there is no true stained glass at all: believers painted cherry blossoms by hand on clear window glass.

On the mapChurches in the villages
Urakami Cathedral, Ōura Cathedral, Kashiragashima Church, Shitsu Church, Kuroshima Church, Dozaki Church. Full chapter atlas and pin sources
1895 to 1925

A farmers' cathedral

Fraineau's cathedral was begun in 1895, to his own design: a Romanesque church of stone and brick. Inflation after two wars slowed it. Fraineau gave his own money, lived in great poverty, and died of overwork on January 24, 1911, after 38 years in Japan, with the walls half built. When stone and brick were landed at the pier, believers competed to carry them up Takaya hill.

His successor, the Belgian Father Raguet, simplified the plan to finish faster. The church was dedicated to the Immaculate Conception. (sources differ) Nagasaki City and the hypocenter park plaque give 1914 for the dedication; the parish history gives March 18, 1915, the day after the 50th anniversary of the Discovery. The twin bell towers were finished in 1925, thirty years after the first stone, with bells from France.

People called it the largest church in the East. It stood on the ground of the headman's house, where the fumi-e had been trodden.

>

Catholic numbers grew from 42,378 in 1890 to 50,302 in 1895, then more slowly to 54,602 in 1900 and 59,437 in 1905.Anti-Western feeling and shrinking mission finances made evangelization harder, and rising costs led some priests to dismiss their catechists.

In September 1905, during the Hibiya riots after the Russo-Japanese peace treaty, rioters burned one Catholic church and two Protestant churches in Tokyo.Shinto, Buddhist and Christian groups then contributed to a fund for the damaged churches, distributing more than 13,000 yen in December 1906.In the Tōhoku famine of 1905, a relief committee including a Catholic missionary and five Protestant missionaries raised and spent about 100,000 yen.

1927

A Japanese bishop

The Church in Japan was becoming Japanese. In 1927 the Diocese of Nagasaki was placed under Japanese leadership, and on October 30 that year Pope Pius XI consecrated in Rome as the first Japanese bishop.

The Japanese hierarchy had been established in 1891, and by 1908 the Church counted thirty-three Japanese priests, twenty-six of them in the Nagasaki diocese.The country had 217 churches and chapels that year, including 122 in the Nagasaki diocese.

1932

Sixty students at Yasukuni

But the conditions written into Article 28 were tightening. The government promoted shrine Shinto as a patriotic duty and called it civic rather than religious. On May 5, 1932 Colonel Kitahara Hitomi, the army officer assigned to , the Jesuit university in Tokyo, marched about sixty preparatory students to , the shrine to Japan's war dead. When the command came to salute the war dead, two students, perhaps three, did not present arms.

The army made it a test. In June the Ministry of Education was told that the army was recalling its officer, because "the spirit of Sophia University did not fall in line with the principles of Japanese education." Archbishop Chambon of Tokyo asked the ministry what the bow meant. On September 30 the vice minister replied that it had "no other purpose than that of manifesting the sentiments of patriotism and loyalty."

The shrine question had occupied the missions well before the Sophia incident: in 1917 Rome sent the apostolic delegate from Manila to Japan to help address it.The 1924 provincial synod in Tokyo also planned a major seminary and regular meetings of the country's bishops.

On the mapYasukuni and beyond
Urakami Cathedral, Yasukuni Shrine, Sophia University, Naze. Full chapter atlas and pin sources
1937 to 1945

Under watch

Elsewhere the pressure was harsher. On Amami Ōshima a local campaign in the 1930s closed the Catholic girls' school, drove out the Church's workers and forced most believers to renounce their faith. The Religious Organizations Law of 1939 placed every religion under state control. It required each religious body to submit its doctrines to the Ministry of Education for approval, so that religion could be mobilized for the national cause.

The pressure on religious bodies intensified after the Manchurian incident of 1931 and the government's campaign to define the national polity in 1935.Catholic schools and welfare institutions continued to operate, but the Church generally avoided political activity.

The ministry at first demanded that Catholics cut their tie with the Pope, then backed down after protests. Western bishops were replaced by Japanese ones, Western heads of Catholic schools gave way to Japanese, and in May 1941 the Church was reorganized as a single body, the Nippon Tenshu Kōkyō Kyōdan, under Archbishop Doi Tatsuo of Tokyo. The historian Hamish Ion judges that Doi, like some Protestant leaders, became a mouthpiece for wartime propaganda, while groups that would not conform, above all the Holiness churches, saw pastors jailed.

By the outbreak of the Pacific War in 1941, ordinary missionary activity had effectively ceased and the Catholic missionary journal Actio Missionaria stopped appearing.Some wartime advocates of a distinctively Japanese Christianity attempted to interpret Christianity through imperial and Shinto concepts.

New Catholics came from outside the old communities, too. Nagai Takashi, born in Shimane in 1908, graduated from Nagasaki Medical College in 1932; an ear infection ended his plan to practice internal medicine, and he turned to radiology. In June 1934 he was baptized with the name Paul, and in August he married Moriyama Midori, from an Urakami Christian family. In July 1937 he went to China as an army doctor and came home in 1940 to head his department. In June 1945 he learned he had leukemia and was given three years to live.

The farmers' cathedral was still standing on Takaya hill. On the morning of August 9, 1945, a priest sat in its confessional hearing confessions before the feast of the Assumption.

Timeline

The dated chapter

Every dated event behind this chapter, with its sources. Filter by section.

  1. February 24, 1873Dajōkan Proclamation No. 68; notice boards removed
  2. 1873Fraineau arrives in Nagasaki
  3. May 29, 1873Pius IX's brief Dum asperrimam
  4. Jul 1874Dysentery and smallpox; de Rotz and the Jūjikai
  5. May 22, 1879Rebuilt Ōura blessed by Bishop Petitjean
  6. 1879De Rotz arrives in Sotome
  7. June 4, 1880Takaya estate bought for 1,600 yen
  8. August 15, 1880First Mass in the temporary church
  9. 1880First small church at Dozaki
  10. 1882Shitsu Church built
  11. 1883Shitsu workshop for village women
  12. 1888Fraineau becomes parish priest of Urakami
  13. 1889Meiji Constitution, Article 28
  14. 1893Ōno chapel built
  15. 1894Unosawa's first stained glass made in Japan
  16. 1895Urakami Cathedral begun
  17. 1902Kuroshima church finished
  18. 1908Present Dozaki church completed by Nohara Yokichi
  19. 1908Tetsukawa builds Nokubi church, Nozaki Island
  20. 1910 to 1919Kashiragashima stone church built
  21. January 24, 1911Fraineau dies
  22. 1914 or March 18, 1915Urakami Cathedral dedicated
  23. 1916Ōso church finished
  24. June 21, 1917Tetsukawa's Egami altar drawing
  25. 1918Egami church finished
  26. 1925Urakami's twin towers finished
  27. October 30, 1927Hayasaka consecrated first Japanese bishop
  28. May 5, 1932Sophia students at Yasukuni
  29. September 30, 1932Ministry of Education: the bow is patriotism and loyalty
  30. December 1, 1932Taguchi's The Catholic View of the State
  31. Jun 1934Nagai Takashi baptized
  32. 1936Pluries instanterque
  33. Jul 1937Nagai goes to China as an army doctor
  34. 1939Religious Organizations Law
  35. May 1941Nippon Tenshu Kōkyō Kyōdan formed under Doi Tatsuo
  36. Jun 1945Nagai diagnosed with leukemia
  37. 1930sCampaign against Catholics on Amami Ōshima
In this chapter

People, places and objects

Pages on this site for the people, places and objects in this chapter. Dashed cards are pages still to come.

Atlas

Every place in this chapter

Each pin is a place named in the chapter. Coordinates come from OpenStreetMap, Wikidata or GSI, as listed. Places without coordinates are listed without a pin.

Exact site (OpenStreetMap, GSI or Wikidata item)Town level only: exact site not yet sourcedKey places in this chapter
PlaceWhy it matters hereCoordinatesCoordinate source
Urakami CathedralTakaya estate 1880; cathedral 1895 to 192532.7761633, 129.8683892OpenStreetMap way/280652259
Ōura CathedralRebuilt 187932.734189, 129.8701625OpenStreetMap way/243003159
Kashiragashima ChurchTetsukawa's stone church, 191933.0124, 129.18286Wikidata Q11664924
Shitsu Church, SotomeDe Rotz's village32.84392, 129.70092Wikidata Q11395699
Kuroshima ChurchMarmand's brick church, 190233.1391534, 129.5370186OpenStreetMap way/418979072
Dozaki Church, FukuePelu's brick church, 190832.7558714, 128.8372523OpenStreetMap way/734662407
Yasukuni ShrineSophia incident, 193235.6942529, 139.7432734OpenStreetMap relation/21067209
Sophia UniversityStudents who would not salute35.68395, 139.7321744OpenStreetMap way/179562477
Naze, Amami ŌshimaAnti-Catholic campaign, 1930s28.37728, 129.49378Wikidata Q1206251
Read next

Where to go from here

Glossary

Words in this chapter

Jūjikai 十字会
The community of young women formed around Father de Rotz in 1874, which raised orphans.
Tōyō ichi 東洋一
"The finest in the East": a period boast for Urakami Cathedral.
kōsatsu 高札
Public notice boards. Their removal in 1873 ended the ban as policy.
Sources

Footnotes

  1. Japan Tourism Agency, "高札撤去:信仰が自由な時代へ" (PDF), source link
  2. National Archives of Japan, "日本のあゆみ," 1873 removal of the notice boards, source link
  3. Urakami Cathedral parish history, "総流配より帰郷後の窮乏 / 仮聖堂の建立," source link
  4. National Diet Library, Birth of the Constitution of Japan, "The Constitution of the Empire of Japan," trans. Ito Miyoji (1889), Article 28, source link
  5. Urakami Cathedral parish history, "本聖堂の建設," source link
  6. Nagasaki City, Nagazine, church series vol. 12, source link
  7. Church Trust, "歴史 / History" (Ōura), source link
  8. Shin-Kamigotō Town Board of Education, notice on Tetsukawa Yosuke's drawings, source link;wcid=j00002x1
  9. Nagasaki Prefecture cultural properties database, "頭ヶ島天主堂," source link
  10. Junshin Seibokai, founder page, "ヤヌワリオ 早坂久之助司教," source link
  11. George H. Minamiki SJ, "The Yasukuni Shrine Incident and the Chinese Rites Controversy," Catholic Historical Review 66:2 (1980), pp. 205 to 229
  12. Aso Masaru, "1930年代奄美大島におけるカトリックをめぐる排撃と「排除の景観」の形成," Jinbun Chiri 63:1 (2011), source link
  13. Japan Center for Asian Historical Records, glossary "宗教団体法," source link
  14. A. Hamish Ion, "The Cross Under an Imperial Sun," in Mullins (ed.), Handbook of Christianity in Japan (Brill, 2003), ch. 4, pp. 69 to 100
  15. Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, memorial database, "浦上天主堂遺壁" (2001 plaque text), source link
  16. National Diet Library, Collaborative Reference Database, entry on Unosawa Tatsuo, source link;page=ref_view ; Matsumoto Stained Glass, history page, source link
  17. Nagasaki Saruku, "東洋一の教会「浦上天主堂」," source link
  18. Nagasaki City Nagai Takashi Memorial Museum, "業績と年表," source link
  19. Urakami Cathedral parish history, "原爆被災," source link
  20. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, "Hidden Christian Sites in the Nagasaki Region" (no. 1495, 2018), source link
  21. Nagasaki Prefecture, おらしょ こころ旅 (World Heritage site), component pages "出津教会堂", "大野教会堂", "旧出津救助院" and "黒島天主堂", source link ; source link ; source link ; source link
  22. IRFA (archives of the Paris Foreign Missions Society), biographical notice 0759, Bernard Petitjean, source link
  23. Nagasaki Prefecture cultural properties database, "堂崎教会," source link ; Gotō City, "堂崎教会," source link
  24. Nagasaki Prefecture, おらしょ こころ旅, "旧野首教会," source link ; column "教会堂に残る鉄川与助のメッセージ," source link
  25. Nagasaki Prefecture cultural properties database, "大曾教会," source link
  26. Miyoshi Chiharu, "Shinto, Nationalism and the Catholic Church in the Early Showa Era," 신학과 철학 (Theology and Philosophy, Sogang University) 18 (2011), pp. 11 to 43 (Taguchi, pp. 32 to 33)
  27. John Breen, chapter with running head "Shinto and Christianity," in Mullins (ed.), Handbook of Christianity in Japan (Brill, 2003), about pp. 249 to 276 (Religious Organizations Law, pp. 266 to 267)
  28. Nagasaki Prefecture, おらしょ こころ旅, "手作りの擬似ステンドグラス," source link ; Naru Island official guide, Egami church, source link
  29. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 334
  30. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 336
  31. Cary 1909 vol. 2, Protestant Missions (Drive file labelled vol. 1), p. 122
  32. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 341
  33. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 354
  34. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 356
  35. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 358
  36. Wilberforce 1897, p. 171
  37. Wilberforce 1897, p. 180
  38. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 355
  39. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 359
  40. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 352
  41. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 361
  42. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 368
  43. Cary 1909 vol. 2, Protestant Missions (Drive file labelled vol. 1), p. 327-328
  44. Cary 1909 vol. 2, Protestant Missions (Drive file labelled vol. 1), p. 328
  45. Cary 1909 vol. 2, Protestant Missions (Drive file labelled vol. 1), p. 341-342
  46. Cary 1909 vol. 1, p. 371
  47. Minamiki 1985 ch. 6, p. 129
  48. Minamiki 1985 ch. 6, p. 135
  49. Mullins Handbook 2003, pp. 70-71
  50. Roggendorf 1963, p. 100 n. 2; p. 107 n. 19
  51. Mullins Handbook 2003, p. 74
  52. Mueller 1967, p. 69
  53. Roberson 2017, p. 18
Images

Image credits

Who's who